The Horror Mystery Box

Love horror merch and a good surprise?

Each Sterye Horror Mystery Box is hand-packed with a varied mix of spooky products, characters, and original designs.

Depending on your box, you may receive:

• Plushies
• Apparel
• Tumblers and drinkware
• Bags and accessories
• Pins and stickers
• Collectibles
• Other spooky surprises

Our boxes pull from different Horror collections, so the items may feature a mix of horror-inspired characters, original Sterye characters, and exclusive (NEVER AI) human designed artwork.

The goal is simple: to make every box feel fun to open, worth the price, and thoughtfully packed with a diverse set of items.

Ordered before?
Leave a note in your cart telling us what you received, and we’ll do our best to avoid duplicates.

Want specific characters?
Leave us a note at checkout and we’ll keep it in mind while packing your box.

⭐ 4.9/5 from 650+ Horror Box reviews
⭐ 4.8/5 from 1,300+ store reviews
Trusted by more than 17,000 customers